Εικόνες σελίδας
PDF
Ηλεκτρ. έκδοση

Opinion of the Court.

(2) Under such an appeal, this court acquires jurisdiction of the entire

case, and of all questions involved in it, and not merely of the

question of constitutionality ; (3) This court ought not to review the question whether the transaction

complained of was an offence against the statute, because the commissioner had jurisdiction of the subject matter involved, and

of the person of H. ; (4) The statute is constitutional ; (5) A statute is a law equally with a treaty, and, if subsequent to and

conflicting with the treaty, supersedes the latter.

The case is stated in the opinion.

Mr. Alfred Taylor and Mr. Herman Aaron for appellant.

Mr. Solicitor General for appellee.

MR. JUSTICE BLATCHFORD delivered the opinion of the court.

On the 10th of August, 1891, a post-office inspector of the United States made complaint on oath before John A. Shields, a United States commissioner for the Southern District of New York, that, on the 29th of December, 1890, Edward H. Horner, of New York City, unlawfully deposited, and caused to be deposited in the post-office at that city, in the State of New York, and in the Southern District of New York, a certain circular, to be conveyed and delivered by mail, which, in the contents thereof, thereafter set forth in the complaint, concerned a lottery, and which was then and there addressed to Joseph Ehrman, 70 Dearborn Street, Chicago, Illinois, and was enclosed in an envelope, with postage thereon prepaid, and carried by mail, and that the circular contained, among other things, what is set forth in the margin,' the further contents of the complaint being also set forth therewith.

16.538.
Banking-house of E. H. Horner, No. 88 Wall street.

“NEW YORK, December 27, 1890. " " Austrian State Bonds of 1864. ••• 110th redemption, December 1st, 1890, at Wien. The following 26 series were called in :

Opinion of the Court.

On the same day the commissioner issued a warrant to the marshal, commanding him to arrest Horner and bring him before the commissioner. This was done, and Horner demanded an examination on the charge, which was had and completed; and the commissioner then certified that it appeared to him, from the testimony offered, that there was probable cause to believe Horner guilty of the offence charged in the warrant, and he committed Horner to the custody of the marshal, in default of $5000 bail, to await the action of the grand jury. By consent, Horner was then discharged, on his own recognizance, until a day named, for the purpose of giving bail, and was subsequently discharged on bail, to await trial.

[blocks in formation]

« 121 " 271 66 280

36 75 22 65 37 54 72 69

20000

24 46 19 16 69 70 28 53 74 82 36 72 82 44 91

24 400

400

63
84

400 400 400

2988

1792
1970

66 461 66 481

3195

2388
2412

" 487 66 493 6 684

400 1000 400 400

400 10000

400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400

3 18

400 2 000

400 5,000

400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 1000

400 2000

2 10 48 88 44 50 14 52 35 39 81

4 14 50

400 50000

400 5000 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400

3238

2483
2526

3486
3685

“ 815

14 56 94 70 82 23 61 81

2531

3969

"853

2666

"All other bonds contained in the above twenty-six series not especially mentioned therein are redeemed with fl. 200. Payment on and after March 1, 1891. The next report of redemption will be published in the second half of the month of January, 1891. Customers who have been notified by special letter of the redemption of their bonds can cash the respective amounts at my office.'

“ That the said words and figures of the said circular relate to and concern, and were understood by Joseph Ehrman to relate to and concern, certain so-called bonds issued by the Empire of Austria, and to state on which of said so-called bonds payments were to be made and the amount thereof.

Opinion of the Court.

On the 17th of November, 1891, Horner was surrendered by his surety, and was committed by the commissioner, in

[ocr errors]

666

[ocr errors]

" The following is a translation of the face of one of such so-called bonds : Series 921. 100 florins.

Number 60. "Premium Bonds. “ • One hundred florins, Austrian standard, as share of the loan of forty million florins, Austrian standard, made according to the law of November 17th, 1863, (Law Journal of the Empire, No. 98,) for which the amount resulting, according to the plan of redemption, will be paid to the bearer by the universal state loan treasury. "Vienna, February 11th, 1864.

(Signed) JOSEPH RUDDE, ". (Coat of arms.)

Imperial-Royal Minister Counsellor.

(Signed) PLENER,

Imperial-Royal Minister of Justice. " • For the board for controlling the state loans :

(Signed) COLLERDO MANNSFELDT. "66 (Signed)

WINTERSTEIN. " For the imperial-royal universal state loan treasury :

(Signed) WINTER.

".(Signed) SCHIMKOWSKY.' “ Each of the so-called bonds has upon its face a series number and a number in the series. The amount of indebtedness which said so-called bond purports to evidence is one hundred (100) florins. The plan of drawing set forth on the back of said so-called bond shows that up to April, 1874, there were to take place five drawings a year, on dates therein stated, which should determine upon which of the so-called bonds payments should be made and the amounts of such payments. That thereafter and until the end of the nineteenth (19th) year after the date of the issue of the so-called bonds, four drawings per year were to take place at stated dates for the same purpose; and that thereafter, to and including the thirty-first (31st) year, three (3) drawings were to take place at fixed dates for each year for the same purpose; and that thereafter, to and including the fifty-fifth (55th) year after the date of issue of such so-called bonds, two (2) drawings per year were to take place for the same purpose; at the end of which time all of said so-called bonds were, according to the plan aforesaid, to be paid; that according to said plan the smallest amount to be paid for any of such so-called bonds selected for payment during the first year after issue was one hundred and thirty-five (135) gulden, during the second year one hundred and forty (140) gulden, and during the third year one hundred and forty-five (145) gulden, and so on, increasing in amount five (5) gulden each year until the amount should reach two hundred (200) gulden, which amount then remained fixed as the minimum sum to be paid for any of the so-called

Opinion of the Court.

default of $5000 bail, to the custody of the marshal on the warrant, to await the action of the grand jury. On the same

bonds whose payment should be determined by the drawings aforesaid; that gulden and florins are denominations of money of the same value; that under the said plan other larger amounts are provided to be paid on certain of the so-called bonds, to be determined by the drawing. Thus, during the first year the following sums are, according to said plan, to be paid on certain so-called bonds, to be determined by such drawing, to wit:

[merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small]

“ And during subsequent periods other provision is made for such larger amounts. That all of the said so-called bonds are in the same form as said copy translation, and have the same drawing and redemption plan endorsed upon them, and are identical in all respects, except that the series numbers and the number thereof vary as to each so-called bond; that deponent produces herewith the original of the so-called bond herein referred to; that all the drawings heretofore referred to by which, first, are determined the series of the so-called bonds to be paid or redeemed in each year, and, second, are determined the particular bonds in the series whose holders shall be entitled to the larger sums aforesaid, the numbers of which are drawn from the wheel, are conducted in such a way as that the determination of the numbers both for redemption and for amounts is wholly by lot or chance. The holder of each so-called bond has an equal chance with the holder of every other so-called bond, first, in securing an early payment of his so-called bond, and, second, in securing, as a so-called payment for his so-called bond, the very large prizes to which reference has already been made, the result in each case, as before alleged, being dependent wholly on lot or chance.

“Wherefore deponent says that the scheme for the so-called redemption of the so-called bonds above referred to is a lottery, and that the depositing of the said circular and the causing thereof to be deposited as above alleged was against the peace and dignity of the United States of America, and contrary to and in violation of section three thousand eight hundred and ninety-four (3894). of the Revised Statutes of the United States, as amended by the act of September nineteenth (19th), one thousand eight hundred and ninety (1890).”

Opinion of the Court.

day, on the petition of Horner, presented to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York, an order was made by that court that writs of habeas corpus and certiorari issue to the marshal and the commissioner, returnable on that day. Returns were made to the writs, and

, on the same day, after counsel were heard, the court, held by Judge Wheeler, made an order dismissing the writ of habeas corpus and remanding Horner to the custody of the marshal. Horner thereupon took an appeal to this court, on November 17, 1891, and was discharged on bail to abide the further action of the Circuit Court on the mandate of this court.

The complaint in this case is founded on § 3894 of the Revised Statutes of the United States, as amended by the act of September 19, 1890, c. 908, (26 Stat. 465,) which reads as follows: “No letter, postal card or circular concerning any lottery, so-called gift concert or other similar enterprise offering prizes dependent upon lot or chance, or concerning schemes devised for the purpose of obtaining money or property under false pretences, and no list of the drawings at any lottery or similar scheme, and no lottery ticket or part thereof, and no check, draft, bill, money, postal note or money order for the purchase of any ticket, tickets, or part thereof, or of any share or any chance in any such lottery or gift enterprise, shall be carried in the mail or delivered at or through any post-office or branch thereof, or by any letter carrier; nor shall any newspaper, circular, pamphlet or publication of any kind containing any advertisement of any lottery or gift enterprise of any kind offering prizes dependent upon lot or chance, or containing any list of prizes awarded at the drawings of any

such lottery or gift enterprise, whether said list is of any part or of all of the drawing, be carried in the mail or delivered by any postmaster or lėtter carrier. Any person who shall knowingly deposit or cause to be deposited, or who shall knowingly send or cause to be sent, anything to be conveyed or delivered by mail in violation of this section, or who shall knowingly cause to be delivered by mail anything herein forbidden to be carried by mail, shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor, and on conviction shall be punished by a fine of not more than five

« ΠροηγούμενηΣυνέχεια »