REPORTS

OF

CASES ARGUED AND DETERMINED

IN THE

SUPREME COURT, OF OHIO.

REPORTED BY

EMILIUS O. RANDALL,

SUPREME COURT REPORTER.

NEW SERIES.

VOLUME LXVIII.

NORWALK. OH10.

THE LANING CO.. PUBLISH BRS,

--

Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1903,

By E. O. RANDALL, FOR THE STATE OF OHIO.
In the Office of the Librarian of Congress at Washington.

JUDGES OF THE
SUPREME COURT OF OHIO.

For the time commencing February 9, 1903, and ending

February 9, 1904.

HON, JACOB F, BURKET, CHIEF JUSTICE.
Hon. WILLIAM T. SPEAR, )
Hon. WILLIAM Z. DAVIS,
Hon. JOHN A. SHAUCK, JUDGES.
Hon. JAMES L. PRICE,
Hon. WILLIAM B. CREW,

ATTORNEY-GENERAL,
Hon. JOHN M. SHEETS.

ASSISTANT ATTORNEY-GENERAL,

GEORGE H. JONES.

Clerk,
LAWSON E. EMERSON.

Deputy Clerks,
JOSEPH G. OBERMEYRE,
ANDREW S. IDDINGS.

Marshal and Law Librarian,
FRANK N. BEEBE.

Assistant Librarians,
E. HOWARD GILKEY,

JOHN W. SHAW.

Marshals of the Court, ANTHONY W. BUCKMASTER,

LOUIS MCCALLISTER.

Reporter,
E. O. RANDALL.

(iv)

JUDGES BY WHOM THE OPINIONS IN THIS

VOLUME WERE WRITTEN

.. 373

176

MR. BURKET, Chief Justice

PAGE
Bobilya v. Priddy, Assignee.......
Electric Street R. R. Co. v. Lohe, Admr..
Goodrich et ux. v. Case, Exr...
Machine Co. v. National Supply Co........
Metropolitan Life Ins, Co. y. Howle
National Bank of Commerce v. Gettinger.......
Northwestern Ohio Natural Gas Co, v. Ullery..

State ex rel. Kemp v. Clarke ........
Mr. SPEAR, Judge

In the Matter of the Estate of Mabel Crawford, Deceased... 58
In the Matter of the Estate of Morrison, Deceased.........
Jewett v. Feldheiser ....

523
Mauk v. Brundage et al..
Miller v. Ewing, Adir....
Savings Bank Co. v. Parisette....

450 Shoemaker v. City of Cincinnati et al.

Vindicator Printing Co. v. State......
MR. DAVIS, Judgem

Bradford Belting Co. v. Gibson.....
Cleveland City Ry. Co. v. First National Bank of N. Y.....
Defiance Water Co. v. City of Defiance.......
Drake Medicine Co. v. Glessner, .....
Eller v. Koehler....
Hutchings v. Davis, Exr..............
Marine Ins. Co. v. Walsh-Upstill Coal Co. (Dissent) ... 486

Overholser v. National Home for Disabled Soldiers......
MR. SHAUCK, Judge-
Aetna Life Ins. Co. v. Dorney.........

......... 151 C., H. & D. Ry, Co. v. City of Troy.......

..........

510
Champion Ice Mfg. Co, v. Penn. Iron Works Co........
First Nat. Bank of Mt. Vernon, O., v. First Nat. Bank of

Lincoln, ill..............
Hassaurek v. Markbreit, Admr...........
Hutchings v. Davis, Exr. (Dissent).........
Shinkle, Wilson & Kreis Co. v. Birney and Seymour. 328
State v. Allen............
Stivens v. Summers

421

160

236