National Reporter System-State Series

THE

PACIFIC REPORTER

WITH KEY-NUMBER ANNOTATIONS

VOLUME 137

PERMANENT EDITION

CONTAINING ALL THE DECISIONS OF THE

!

SUPREME COURTS OF CALIFORNIA, KANSAS, OREGON, WASHINGTON
COLORADO, MONTANA, ARIZONA, NEVADA, IDAHO, WYOMING
UTAH, NEW MEXICO, OKLAHOMA, COURTS OF APPEAL
OF CALIFORNIA AND COLORADO, AND CRIMINAL

COURT OF APPEALS OF OKLAHOMA

WITH TABLE OF PACIFIC CASES IN WHICH REHEARINGS

HAVE BEEN DENIED

JANUARY 19 - FEBRUARY 16, 1914

KF

COPYRIGHT, 1914

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY

(137 Pac.)

WILLIAM H. BEATTY, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
F. W. HENSHAW.

W. G. LORIGAN.
F. M. ANGELLOTTI.

M. C. SLOSS.
LUCIEN SHAW.

HENRY A. MELVIN.

District Courts of Appeal.

First District.
THOS. J. LENNON, PRESIDING JUSTICE.
F. H. KERRIGAN.1

JOHN E. RICHARDS.

Second District.

N. P. CONREY, PRESIDING JUSTICE.
VICTOR E. SHAW.

W. P. JAMES.

Third District.
N. P. CHIPMAN, PRESIDING JUSTICE. 1
E. C. HART.

A. G. BURNETT.

COLORADO—Supreme Court.

GEORGE W. MUSSER, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
WILLIAM H. GABBERT.

JAMES E. GARRIGUES
S. HARRISON WHITE.

MORTON S. BAILEY.
WILLIAM A. HILL.

TULLY SCOTT.

Court of Appeals.

LOUIS W. CUNNINGHAM, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
ALFRED R. KING.

WILLIAM B. MORGAN.
EDWIN W. HURLBUT.

JOHN C. BELL

*J. D. Murphy served as judge pro tem.

596987

SAMUEL W. HAYES, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
R. L. WILLIAMS.

JOHN B. TURNER.
MATTHEW J. KANE.

R. H. LOOFBOURROW.

SUPREME COURT COMMISSIONERB.

Division No. 1.
J. B. A. ROBERTSON.2

CHAS. M. THACKER.
J. F. SHARP.

GEO. B. RITTENHOUSE.S

Division No. 2.
PHIL. D. BREWER.

JNO. B. HARRISON.
C. A. GALBRAITH.

Criminal Court of Appeals.

JAS. R. ARMSTRONG, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
THOMAS H. DOYLE.

HENRY M. FURMAN,

2 Resignation effective February 1, 1914

Appointed February 2, 1914