Epistemology After Protagoras: Responses to Relativism in Plato, Aristotle, and Democritus
Clarendon Press, 2005 - 291 σελίδες
Relativism, the position that things are for each as they seem to each, was first formulated in Western philosophy by Protagoras, the 5th century BC Greek orator and teacher. Mi-Kyoung Lee focuses on the challenge to the possibility of expert knowledge posed by Protagoras, together with responses by the three most important philosophers of the next generation, Plato, Aristotle, and Democritus. In his book Truth, Protagoras made vivid use of two provocative but imperfectly spelled out ideas: first, that we are all "measures" of the truth and that we are each already capable of determining how things are for ourselves, since the senses are our best and most credible guides to the truth; second, given that things appear differently to different people, there is no basis on which to decide that one appearance is true rather than the other. Plato developed these ideas into a more fully worked-out theory, which he then subjected to refutation in the Theaetetus. Aristotle argued that Protagoras' ideas lead to skepticism in Metaphysics Book G, a chapter which reflects awareness of Plato's reaction in the Theaetetus. And finally Democritus incorporated modified Protagorean ideas and arguments into his theory of knowledge and perception.
There have been many important recent studies of these thinkers in isolation. However, there has been no attempt to tell a single, coherent story about how Democritus, Plato, and Aristotle responded to Protagoras' striking claim, and to its perceived implications about knowledge, perception, and truth. By studying these four figures in relation to each other, we arrive at a better understanding of an important chapter in the development of Greek epistemology.
Τι λένε οι χρήστες - Σύνταξη κριτικής
Δεν εντοπίσαμε κριτικές στις συνήθεις τοποθεσίες.
Protagoras and relativism
Selfrefutation and contradiction
The Secret Doctrine in Platos Theaetetus
Aristotle on Protagoras and the Theaetetus
Aristotle on Protagoras and early conceptions of thinking
Άλλες εκδόσεις - Προβολή όλων
according affected alteration answer appearances argues argument Aristotle Aristotle's atoms become beliefs body Burnyeat cause claim clear cold colour comes committed concerning conclusion condition conflicting appearances contradictions definition Democritus denies depends describes discussion everything evidence example exist experience explain fact false flux follows fragment give given idea implies impossible interpretation judge judgement kind knowledge least means measure doctrine Metaphysics mind nature notes object occurs one's opinion opposite perceiving perception person philosophers Plato position possible present principle produce properties Protagoras question reality reason refer refutation relation relative relativism relativist respect sceptical Secret Doctrine seems senses sensible qualities Sextus shape Socrates someone sources suggests suppose sweet tell term Theaetetus Theophrastus theory thesis things thinking thought trans translation true truth understand δε και μεν