OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. FEBRUARY 3, 1896. FIRST CIRCUIT. Comprising Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island JUSTICE HORACE GRAY, of Massachusetts. Appointed December 20, 1881, by Presi dent Arthur. SECOND CIRCUIT. Comprising Connecticut, New York, and Vermont. JUSTICE RUFUS W. PECKHAM, of New York. Appointed December 9, 1895, by President Cleveland. THIRD CIRCUIT. Comprising Delaware, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. JUSTICE GEORGE SHIRAS, JR., of Pennsylvania. Appointed July 26, 1892, by Presi dent Harrison. FOURTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia. CHIEF JUSTICE MELVILLE W. FULLER, of Illinois. Appointed July 20, 1888, by President Cleveland. FIFTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas. JUSTICE EDWARD D. WHITE of Louisiana. Appointed February 19, 1894, by President Cleveland. SIXTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, and Tennessee. JUSTICE JOHN M. HARLAN, of Kentucky. Appointed November 29, 1877, by Presldent Hayes. SEVENTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin. JUSTICE HENRY BILLINGS BROWN, of Michigan. Appointed December 29, 1890, by President Harrison. EIGHTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Arkansas, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Wyoming. JUSTICE DAVID J. BREWER, of Kansas. Appointed December 18, 1889, by President Harrison. NINTH CIRCUIT. Comprising California, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington. JUSTICE STEPHEN J. FIELD, of California. Appointed March 10, 1863, by President Lincoln. 16 796 346 170 184 16 16 197 16 Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. 1 16 725 283 16 828 339 16 850 410 16 435 16 799 499 16 864 602 16 875 91 16 766 290 16 843 411 16 802 439 16 853 512 16 885 613 16 895 167 16 794 291 16 820 359 16 848 415 16 803 466 16 16 695 313 16 839 366 16 831 419 16 804 478 16 700 324 16 801 383 814 4.20 16 798 490 16 666 326 16 795 399 837 425 16 805 498 16 754 329 16 810 404 808 16 S.CT. Pg. 16 859 529 16 871 592 16 879 625 16 952 890 650 16 934 904 664 16 943 900 687 16 923 (v) CASES REPORTED. iv Abbeville County, Folsom v. (159 U. S. 611) .... Page 174 A. B. Kahnweiler & Bro. v. Phenix Ins. Co. of Brooklyn, N. Y. (163 U. S. 691)..1202 Adams, The Warren (163 U. S. 679). .1199 Advance, The (163 U. S. 690). .1202 Aetna Life Ins. Co. v. Florida (163 U. S. 675) .1198 Ainsa v. United States (161 U. S. 208)... 544 Alberty v. United States (162 U. S. 499).. 864 Albuquerque Hotel & Opera House Co., Medler v. (163 U. S. 695). Allen v. Cannon (163 U. S. 675). Allen, United States v. (163 U. S. 499)...1071 Allianca, The (163 U. S. 690). ..1202 Allison v. United States (160 U. S. 203).. 252 American Bell Tel. Co., United States v. (159 U. S. 548).. 1204 .1198 69 American Dock & Improvement Co. v. City of Jersey City (163 U. S. 675). American Sugar Refining Co., The Centurion v. (163 U. S. 705)... American Waterworks Co. of Illinois v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. (163 U. S. 675) ..1198 ..1199 .1198 .1198 .1198 Andrews v. Thum (163 U. S. 676). ... 412 853 554 Baca v. United States (163 U. S. 676)....1198 105 ... Page 637 Beall, Dushane v. (161 U. S. 513). Bear Lake & River Waterworks & Irrigation Co., Garland v. (163 U. S. 687)....1201 Beck, Flournoy Live-Stock & Real-Estate Co. v. (163 U. S. 686). .1201 Beebe v. United States (161 U. S. 104). 532 Belknap v. Schild (161 U. S. 10). 443 Bellingham Bay Land Co., Dibble v. (163 U. S. 63). Bent, Singer Manufg Co. v. (163 U. S. 205) Bertha Zine & Mineral Co. v. Carrico (163) U. S. 678). Beverly, Barnitz v. (163 U. S. 118). Black v. Black (163 U. S. 678). Black v. Elkhorn Min. Co. (163 U. 445) Blagge v. Balch (162 U. S. 439). Blout, Cochran v. (161 U. S. 350). Board of Equalization of Buchanan County, Mo., State of Missouri v. (163 U. S. 696) Board of Flour Inspectors for Port of New Orleans v. Glover (160 U. S. 170).. Board of Flour Inspectors for Port of New Orleans v. Glover (161 U. S. 101).. Board of Harbor Line Commissioners, State of Washington v. (163 U. S. 710). Board of Tide Land Appraisers of Whatcom County, State of Washington v. (163 U. S. 711).. 492 .1206 Bonsack Mach. Co., Pollard v. (163 U. S. 700) ...... Booth v. Crawford (163 U. S. 678) ....1206 .1205 1199 34 571 803 72 853 29 644 .1159 875 ... 585 803 802 Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. Sutherland (163 U. S. 676). .... Baltimore & O. & C. R. Co. v. Yarde (163 U. S. 677). .1199 .1198 City of Harrisburg, Barber Asphalt Paving Co. v. (163 U. S. 677).. Central R. Co. of New Jersey v. Keegan (160 U. S. 259). Central Railroad & Banking Co. of Georgia, Southwestern R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 705) 113 Central Trust Co. of New York v. Rich- .1199 .1208 .1198 City of Jersey City, American Dock & Improvement Co. v. (163 U. S. 675). .1198 City of Mattoon, Illinois Cent. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 690). City of New Orleans v. United States (163 U. S. 697). .1202 ..1200 .1204 City of New Orleans, New Orleans C. & L. ...1198 .....1205 ...... 231 239 Cloughley, Rouse v. (163 U. S. 702). Cloyd, Wheeler v. (163 U. S. 711). .1208 Clune v. United States (159 U. S. 590).. 125 Cochran v. Blout (161 U. S. 350). 454 Codman, Brooks v. (162 U. S. 439).. 853 Coeur D'Alene R. & Nav. Co., Washington & I. R. Co. v. (160 U. S. 77).. Coeur D'Alene R. & Nav. Co., Washington & I. R. Co. v. (160 U. S. 101). Coffin v. United States (162 U. S. 664).... 943 Collins, Wayne Lumber Co. v. (163 U. S. 711) .1208 Colorado Eastern R. Co., Union Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 708). Columbia v. Lyon (161 U. S. 200). Columbia, Washington Gaslight Co. v. (161 U. S. 316).. ... 848 .1207 .1208 450 .1199 564 Chase Elevator Co., Richards v. (159 U. S. 477).. Chaves, United States v. (159 U. S. 452) 57 417 439 .1208 Connecticut, Geer v. (161 U. S. 519). 600 497 914 75 .1204 Cook v. Eells (163 U. S. 681). .1200 .1199 Chicago, R. I. & P. R. Co., Union Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 564). .1173 Cook, Missouri, K. & T. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 491). ..1093 Cooper v. United States (163 U. S. 682)...1200 Cooper, Girard Insurance & Trust Co. v. (162 U. S. 529). 879 .1018 Chilton, Union Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. |