REPORTS OF CASES

DETERMINED IN

THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

OCTOBER 4, 1920 TO FEBRUARY 1, 1921

RANDOLPH V. WHITING
REPORTER

VOLUME 184

SAN FRANCISCO
BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY

1922

Copyright 1922

BY

BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY

SAN FRANCISCO
THE FILMER BROTHERS ELECTROTYPE COMPANY
TYPOGRAPHERS AND STEREOTYPERS

SUPREME COURT.

FRANK M. ANGELLOTTI, Chief Justice.

DEPARTMENT ONE.

LUCIEN SHAW, Presiding Justice.
WILLIAM P. LAWLOR, Justice.
WARREN OLNEY, JR., Justice.

DEPARTMENT TWO.

CURTIS D. WILBUR, Presiding Justice.

THOMAS J. LENNON, Justice.
WILLIAM A. SLOANE, Justice.

J. H. RICRDAN..

R. T. MCKISICK....
J. CHARLES JONES...
FRANK L. GUERENA..
FRANK J. ENGLISH.

LEON FRENCH....
ARTHUR KEETCH...
RANDOLPH V. WHITING.....
FRED L. STEWART..
HENRY F. WRIGLEY.

WILLIAM F. TRAVERSO.
B. GRANT TAYLOR...
W. R. MACKRILLE.....

..Deputy Attorney-General

..Deputy Attorney-General

.Deputy Attorney-General

.Deputy Attorney-General

.Deputy Attorney-General
.Deputy Attorney-General
.Deputy Attorney-General
.Reporter

.First Assistant Reporter Second Assistant Reporter Third Assistant Reporter ....Clerk

Chief Deputy Clerk, San Francisco

(iii)