SCOTS REVISED REPORTS

COURT OF SESSION SERIES

General Editor.

JOHN RANKINE, Esq., K.C., M.A., LL.D.

ASSISTED BY

WILLIAM HARVEY, ESQ., B.A., LL.B.,

AND ROBERT BERRY, ESQ.

Consultative Committee.

THE RIGHT HON. LORD KINROSS, LORD JUSTICE-GENERAL.

THE HON. LORD M'LAREN.

CHAS. SCOTT DICKSON, ESQ., K.C., LORD ADVocate.

REVISED REPORTS

COURT OF SESSION

THIRD SERIES VOLUME X

CONTAINING

MACPHERSON X

1871-72

EDINBURGH

WILLIAM GREEN & SONS

LAW PUBLISHERS

1904

PRINTED BY MORRISON AND GIBB LIMITED

FOR

WILLIAM GREEN & SONS

NOVEMBER 1904

94070

JUDGES

OF THE

COURT OF SESSION

DURING THE PERIOD OF THESE REPORTS.

FIRST DIVISION.

Lord President, the Right Hon. JOHN INGLIS.

Lord DEAS.

Lord ARDMILLAN.

Lord KINLOCH.

1

SECOND DIVISION.

Lord Justice-Clerk, the Right Hon. Sir JAMES

MONCREIFF, Bart.

Lord CoWAN.

Lord BENHOLME.

Lord NEAVES.