 The judge has to say whether any facts have been established by evidence from which negligence may be reasonably inferred : the jurors have to say whether from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion,...  Reports of Cases Argued and Determined in the Supreme Court of Judicature of ... - Σελίδα 422των Indiana. Supreme Court, Horace E. Carter, Albert Gallatin Porter, Gordon Tanner, Benjamin Harrison, Michael Crawford Kerr, James Buckley Black, Francis Marion Dice, Augustus Newton Martin, John Worth Kern, John Lewis Griffiths, Sidney Romelee Moon, Charles Frederick Remy - 1888Πλήρης προβολή - Σχετικά με αυτό το βιβλίο
 | Alexander Wood Renton, Maxwell Alexander Robertson - 1907 - 712 σελίδες
...to say whether, from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration...the judge were to withdraw the case from the jury on the ground that, in his opinion, negligence ought not to be inferred; and it would, on the other... | |
 | Sir John William Salmond - 1907 - 574 σελίδες
...to say whether from these facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration...maintained, and should be maintained distinct It would . . . . place in the hands of the jurors a power which might be exercised in the most arbitrary manner,... | |
 | Frederick Pollock - 1912 - 768 σελίδες
...213, 43 L. per Lord Ha'.sbury, 12 App. Cn. JQB 151 (1873-4). at p. 43. (y) 3 App. Ca. 193, 47 LJ tion of justice that these separate functions should be...distinct. It would be a serious inroad on the province of a jury, if in a caso where there are facts from which negligence may reasonably be inferred, the judge... | |
 | Edward Betley Brown, L. S. Le Vernois, Esten Kenneth Williams - 1915 - 1004 σελίδες
...to say whether from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration...distinct. It would be a serious inroad on the province of a jury if, in a case where there are facts from which negligence may reasonably be inferred, the judge... | |
 | Indiana. Appellate Court - 1915 - 854 σελίδες
...to say whether, from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration...maintained, and should be maintained distinct.' " It is also urged that, in the absence of other evidence of the cause of the fall of the scaffold, it was... | |
 | Sir William Searle Holdsworth - 1928 - 220 σελίδες
...prerogative as judge of the fact; and to prevent both from being infringed. "It is," said Lord Cairns,86 "of the greatest importance in the administration of justice that these separate functions [of judge and jury] should be maintained, and should be maintained distinct. It would be a serious... | |
 | New Brunswick. Supreme Court - 1882 - 672 σελίδες
...has to say whether from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is my opinion of the greatest importance in the administration of justice that those separate functions should be maintained distinct. It would be a serious inroad on the province... | |
 | 1888 - 1036 σελίδες
...to say whether, from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is in my opinion of the greatest importance, in the administration...withdraw the case from the jury upon the ground that, in bis opinion, negligence ought not to be inferred; and it would, on the other band, place in the hands... | |
 | 1878 - 842 σελίδες
...to say whether from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration of justice that those separate functions should be maintained distinct. It would be a serious inroad on the province... | |
 | 1920 - 588 σελίδες
...to say whether from these facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration of justice that these two separate functions should be maintained and should be maintained distinct. It would be a serious... | |
| |
